If you have just tried comparing car insurance on a few sites, you’ll know how difficult it can be to find good car insurance in Australia at the moment. Premiums have increased significantly. To help you through this process, I have written this AAMI car insurance quote review. This way you can cut through the marketing and know exactly what you are getting.
Every year I help my friends and family review their car insurance. If they are getting a low quote, I always remind them to check the Product Disclosure Statement. If there is something missing in that document, you may be in trouble when you come to make a claim. Below, I will guide you through how AAMI car insurance works within the quoting process. I have highlighted where you can get value from this product, and where you can fall into traps on the final screen.
AAMI Car Insurance Quote Review
I used the AAMI website to get a new quote for a 5 year old SUV, in a suburban driveway.
Quick process
AAMI has a very quick quoting process. By searching in your state and entering your registration number, your car make, model and specifications will be picked up from your registration. Within 5 minutes, you can view the price.
Discounts
AAMI advertise this discount prominently on the quote page. At the moment, if you purchase a new comprehensive policy from AAMI online, you get a $50 discount. This is great for the first 12 months of your policy. However, as I keep an eye on car insurance prices, I always remind people to be cautious of discounts on first years of policies. Set yourself a calendar alert for 11 months from now, as this discount will not be applied to your policy when you receive a renewal notice.
Market Value vs Agreed Value
Once you can see the price, you get to choose whether to insure your car at Market Value or Agreed Value.
Note: in my quote, I had to be careful as it was set by default to give me a cheaper price.
Market Value means that if you get into an accident and your car gets written off, AAMI will pay you the value that they determine your car had right before the accident. Given that the used car market in Australia has been decreasing in price, this is often significantly less than what you expect.
Agreed Value means that you and AAMI agree on a specific price for your car. If it is stolen or written off, you will be paid this amount.
If you are in a car finance or novated lease, I would recommend changing your quote to Agreed Value. Ensure that the Agreed Value covers the loan for your car. This will mean that your premium increases by a small amount each month, but it means you will not be paying a bank to own a car in a wrecking yard.
Add-ons to watch out for
Many people get caught out with these. To give competitive prices on comprehensive car insurance, AAMI no longer include these add-ons as standard, meaning you can choose to pay extra for them.
Scroll through your quote and ensure you tick these boxes:
1. Windscreen and Windows Cover
If you get a rock in your windscreen on the motorway, getting a new windscreen (with features such as rain sensors and lane keeping cameras) can cost over $1000. In a basic AAMI quote, if you get a crack on your windscreen, you will be charged your full excess. If you pay slightly more to add on windscreen cover to your quote, you will be able to get 1 replacement windscreen in a year with no excess. If you are regularly on the motorways, I would recommend adding this.
2. Hire Car
Be very careful with this part. In a comprehensive AAMI policy, you get a hire car if your car was stolen, or in an accident that was not your fault (if you can provide the name, address and registration number of the driver at fault).
However, if you were at fault in an accident, or got into an accident with someone who hit your parked car in the shops and drove off without leaving a note, you will not be provided with a hire car unless you added the Hire Car After an Event add on.
3. No Choice of Repairer
This is a common complaint on online reviews. AAMI do not allow you to choose your preferred repairer, and you cannot pay to add this in.
If you have an accident, you must take your car to one of AAMI’s partner repairers. However, AAMI promise a lifetime guarantee on the quality of the repairs, and you do not have to worry about getting quotes or arranging a tow. For 90% of people driving a Toyota, Mazda or Hyundai to work every day, this is perfect and extremely convenient.
However, if you have a modified 4WD/Classic car/Prestige European car and only trust a specific panel beater to repair it, then AAMI is not suitable for you.
AAMI Car Insurance Quote Review – Hidden Costs and Excess
Flexi Premiums
On the AAMI quote page, you can choose to increase your standard excess to get a lower premium. If you are a very safe driver and do not make many small claims, increasing your standard excess by a few hundred can significantly reduce your quote.
If any younger people in your family are driving your car, make sure to be aware of the excess. As with most insurers in Australia, if a driver under 25 or with less than 2 years experience is driving your car, they will be charged extra excess on top of the standard excess. Whilst it is convenient that you do not have to add every occasional driver to your quote, if a young driver uses your keys and hits a bollard, it will be very expensive.
Read also: Business Vehicle Insurance in Australia
Third Party Quotes
If you have an older car worth less than $5000, you may find that a comprehensive policy costs 1/3 of your cars value.
I also got a Third Party Property Damage quote. Something to note with this quote is the Uninsured Motorist Extension. If you get into an accident with an uninsured driver and only have basic Third Party Property Damage insurance with AAMI, AAMI will still pay up to $5000 to repair your car (as long as it wasn’t your fault and you can identify the other driver). This is a great extra to have on a cheap quote.
My Final thoughts
AAMI is one of the largest insurers in Australia and for a reason. With Suncorp as backing, the claims process and app is very easy to use. If you don’t care too much about choosing your own panel beater, the lifetime guarantee on repairs is very reassuring. However, if you do care about this, be aware.
In conclusion, I would recommend that in your quote, you change between Market Value and Agreed Value to see the price differences. Also try adjusting the flexi premium excess to fit your budget. I hope this AAMI car insurance quote review helps you to understand what you are actually getting in this insurance policy, and make sure that you are not falling into any traps or paying for unnecessary add ons.
Marvin Lambert
Marvin LambertMarvin Lambert is a finance professional and financial advisor specializing in lending solutions, Car Insurance, personal finance, and consumer credit education. Through his writing, he helps readers understand practical money management strategies, borrowing decisions, and financial planning concepts in simple, actionable terms.
