How to Compare Bundled Home and Auto Insurance Quotes on Equal Terms

Don’t Fall for the Cheap Quote: How to Compare Home and Auto Insurance Bundles on Equal Terms

You’ve seen these ads! Get a discount on your home and car insurance and save hundreds of dollars!

You then check around and enter your details into 3 different sites. 3 different quotes come back. Company A: $3,200, Company B: $2,800, Company C: $1,900.

You’re tempted to choose Company C and save that cash.

Don’t be so quick! When I was first looking for a bundled insurance, I almost fell into this trap. Just before I signed up with the cheapest quote, I checked the small print. The ‘cheap’ policy had doubled my home excess, removed my rental car coverage, and reduced the maximum payout if my roof was written off.

I wasn’t getting a better deal. I was getting worse insurance.

Compare Bundled Home and Auto Insurance Quotes on Equal Terms

In order to see the true best deal, you need to do an ‘apples to apples’ comparison. Below is my method.

1. Check your current policy

Start by checking your current declarations pages for both your home and car.

These are known in insurance circles as dec pages. They give a one page summary of your current cover and premium.

When speaking to an agent or inputting details online, make sure to check your current policy details from your dec page. Ask them to match your current level of cover. Once you can compare the price of this against your current policy, you can decide whether to increase or reduce cover.

2. Match rebuild value

The largest figure in your home insurance is the dwelling cover / coverage A. This is the maximum amount that you would get if your house was completely destroyed.

The issue here is that every insurer will calculate a different rebuild cost for your property. So company A may have a rebuild cost of $350,000, and company B may have a rebuild cost of $425,000.

As expected, the price of the policy for $350,000 will be much cheaper.

To even the playing field, take the largest rebuild value and ask the other companies to match that value. This will mean you get an ‘apples to apples’ comparison. (Note: Rebuild values have nothing to do with what your house is worth in the property market. It is simply the cost of materials and labour to replace the structure).

3. Request Replacement Value Cover

This is an especially sneaky trick in insurance. Look at the value of your roof and contents in the quotes. You should see either Replacement Value or Actual Cash Value (ACV).

Replacement Value means that you will be reimbursed for a brand new replacement.

Actual Cash Value means that you get money based on what you could sell your item for on sites like Craigslist.

If a storm destroys your 12 year old roof, and a new roof costs $15,000, with replacement value cover you would get $15,000 (minus your excess). With Actual Cash Value cover, the insurer will reduce the price of your roof by 12 years of depreciation. Therefore, you may only get $4,000 from the insurer, and you would be out of pocket $11,000.

Make sure that in all of your quotes you have replacement value cover on your roof and contents. If any of the quotes have Actual Cash Value, reject it or ask them to change.

4. Be cautious of percentage excesses

An excess is the amount of money you have to pay before the insurer pays anything.

On your car insurance, just make sure that all of the quotes have the same excess for collision and comprehensive cover. Say $500 or $1,000.

On your home insurance, watch out for percentage excesses for wind and hail damage.

Quote A may have a flat excess of $1,500, and Quote B may have a $1,500 excess for fire damage, but a 2% excess for wind/hail damage. If your home is valued for $400,000, a 2% excess means you pay $8,000 before the insurer pays anything towards storm damage.

Be very careful when looking at your excess. Ensure that all quotes have either the same flat excess amount, or the same percentage.

5. Match Liability limits

On car insurance, there will be 3 numbers in your quote. For example 100/300/100.

Each number represents how much liability cover you have in thousands of dollars.

$100,000 = Covers the maximum amount for 1 person you injure in an accident.

$300,000 = Covers the maximum amount for all people injured in the accident.

$100,000 = Covers the maximum amount for damage to property (cars, fences, buildings).

However, when you search for cheap insurance online, the algorithm will often reduce these to the minimum levels required by law in your state (sometimes as low as 25/50/25). Although the price will be very cheap, you are putting yourself in a risky position if you get into a bad accident.

Ensure that all quotes have the same 3 numbers.

6. Check add ons

At the bottom of your quotes, you may see some extra covers included. These are known as endorsements or riders.

Some quotes will include these as standard, and some won’t in order to give a cheaper price. Check for:

Water backup cover (Home). Water backup and broken sump pumps are not covered in standard policies. Ensure all quotes have at least $5,000 – $10,000 of this cover.

Service line cover (Home). If underground water or power lines break in your home, this will pay to dig up your garden to repair them.

Breakdown and rental cover (Car). If you rely on your car to get to work, ensure that all quotes include rental cover so that you aren’t left stranded following a minor accident.

Bundling may not be cheaper!

Insurance companies love giving discounts for multiple policies, as they know that if you have both your car and home insurance with them, it is very unlikely that you will switch providers. It would be too much hassle to switch both policies.

However, because they know you are a loyal customer, they may gradually increase your premiums each year.

Once you have evened up all of your quotes, do a final calculation. Sometimes, one provider may give a great price on car insurance, whilst another provider may give an incredible price on home insurance.

Even without the multi-policy discount, it may be cheaper to purchase your car insurance from Company A, and your home insurance from Company B.

Take 20 minutes to do a side by side comparison of your quotes. Highlight the differences between the quotes. Once you have forced the companies to be on a level playing field, it will be clear which provider is giving you the best deal.

Marvin Lambert is a finance professional and financial advisor specializing in lending solutions, personal finance, and consumer credit education.

Marvin Lambert

Marvin Lambert

Marvin Lambert is a finance professional and financial advisor specializing in lending solutions, Car Insurance, personal finance, and consumer credit education. Through his writing, he helps readers understand practical money management strategies, borrowing decisions, and financial planning concepts in simple, actionable terms.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *